Xcel Men's Heathered VentX Short Sleeve Surf Tee

I purchased a half dozen of these shirts from Amazon about 2 years ago. Love them. They're getting a bit frayed so I thought I'd buy some more. None available on Amazon. Swimoutlet had them and I ordered 6. Three in grey, three in black. All these new shirts have the same tag number as the old one but none of them fit correctly. They're all too small. The label reads large but they seem like mediums with shorter sleeves. I would suggest you buy one and try it on before buying more case the size just doesn't seem right. I wonder if these were seconds. 282 is the new shirt in the pix.