I really like these swim shorts.  The material is ultra soft and stretches as adverstised.  They are also lightweight in the water and out.  The zipper pocket is perfect for my needs.  I have short legs, so the shorts fall just past my knees.  This is the only drawback I have.  I'd prefer at or just above otherwise I'd give 5 stars.  The extra details, such as the rubber on the drawstring, are a very nice touch.

I got these for swimming and they are really nice and true to size; a high quality product. But beware, the black, yellow and pewter color combination is really black yellow and bright white. For me it detracts from the look and I may exchange it for the pewter black and red.
I would have given it 5 stars, because of the overall quality of the product, The color scheme is just personal taste.